Raccolta · Centro Conservazione Restauro La Venaria Reale
Centro Conservazione Restauro La Venaria Reale
Letto automaticamente dal PDF: può contenere errori.
a Centro Conservazione Restauro
LA VENARIA REALE
Proceedings
2020
YOUNG
PROFESSIONALS
FORUM
EMERGING SKILLS FOR
HERITAGE CONSERVATION
July, 2 2020
First edition
Edited by Fondazione Centro per la
Conservazione e il Restauro dei beni culturali “La Venaria Reale”
Partner
Scientific Committee
Sara Abram - CCR, Secretary General
Lorenzo Appolonia - CCR, Scientific
Laboratories Director
Michela Cardinali - CCR, Conservation
Laboratories and Advanced Training and Study School Director Stefania De Blasi - CCR, Head of
Documentation and Communication
Maria Beatrice Failla - UniTo, University of Turin, Associate Professor Alberto Garlandini - ICOM, International Council of Museums, President
Costanza Miliani - CNR, National
Research Council of Italy, Director
Sarah Stannage - IIC, International
Institute for Conservation, Executive
Director
The Young Professionals Forum team
Sara Stoisa
Valentina Valcarenghi
Communication team
Maria Elena Delia
Marta Franceschetti
Lorenza Ghionna
Cosimo Morleo
Contacts www.centrorestaurovenaria.it youproforum@centrorestaurovenaria.it The reproduction of texts and images, even partial, without authorization is prohibited. Venaria Reale, December 2020
This publication in PDF format is available for download at www.centrorestaurovenaria.it Acknowledgement
Ruben Abbattista - IED, 20th edition of the Master in Marketing and Communication teacher Alberto Anfossi - Fondazione
Compagnia di San Paolo, Secretary
General
Fabio Angelosanto – CCR, IT services
Federica Basile - IED, teaching assistant Alessandra Bellino – CCR, Past Head of HR and Administration dept. Rosanna Binacchi - MiBACT, Director of International Relations
Elena Bozzo - CCR, Coordinator of
Administration dept. Francesca Cardinali - SIC, Italia
Manager
Lucia D'Ambrosa, IED, Responsabile
Coordinamento Didattica
Elena Giacoia - CCR, Legal affairs
Maria Teresa Jaquinta - ICCROM, Senior Project Manager
Webber Ndoro - ICCROM, Director general Austin Nevin – IIC, Vice-President and Head of Conservation at Courtauld Institute of Art
Beatrice Perris - Fondazione Magnetto
Alessio Re - Fondazione Santagata, Secretary General
Elena Roveta - Fondazione Magnetto
Silvia Sabato - CCR, Senior
Expert, Strategic and International
Development
Caitlin Southwick - Ki Culture, Founder/Executive Director
20 th edition of the Master in Marketing and Communication of Istituto Europeo di Design (IED) students
Sagep Editori
Direzione editoriale
Alessandro Avanzino
Redazione
Sara Piselli
Grafica
Barbara Ottonello, Matteo Pagano
Impaginazione
Matteo Pagano
Progetto digitale
Fabrizio Fazzari
Traduzioni
Alex Gillan www.sagep.it ©2020 CCR La Venaria Reale ©2020 Sagep Editori With the patronage of
In collaboration with
The Young Professionals Forum is supported by the CCR’s Strategic Plan 2019-2022 and financed by Fondazione Compagnia di San Paolo. The awards for the best papers in each session were sponsored by Fondazione Magnetto.
3 INSTITUTIONAL INTRODUCTION
Stefano Trucco, CCR president
Alberto Anfossi, Fondazione Compagnia di San Paolo Secretary General 8 FOREWORD
Sara Abram, CCR Secretary General
Alessio Re, Fondazione Santagata per l’Economia della Cultura Secretary General 10 INTRODUCTION
Webber Ndoro, ICCROM director general
12 SESSION 1
Michela Cardinali and Sarah Stannage
16 Munyaradzi Elton Sagiya – Zimbabwe (Winner Of The Session 1) INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE SKILLS AND PRACTICES
IN CONSERVING DRY-STONE WALLS AT GREAT ZIMBABWE WORLD
HERITAGE SITE
33
Francesca Gasparetto, Alice Devecchi - Italy
DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES FOR AN OPEN CULTURAL HERITAGE
39
Claudia Alejandra Garza - Mexico
CONSERVATION OF DEVOTIONAL HERITAGE IN THE GREATER
MEXICO CITY AREA
48
NagmEldeen Morshed Hamza - Egypt
CONSERVATION PRACTICES BETWEEN PAST AND PRESENT
AN INTEGRATED APPROACH ABOUT CONSERVATION DECISION- MAKING CHALLENGES
51
Ilaria Marrone – Italy
THE RESTORATION OF THREE CONTEMPORARY PLASTIC MASKS
STUDY, PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT
58
Harpreet Tanday – India
THE SHEKHAWATI PROJECT
UNDERSTANDING CULTURAL HERITAGE THROUGH DIFFERENT
CONCEPTS AND CHALLENGES IN RAJASTHAN (INDIA)
SUMMARY
66 SESSION 2
Lorenzo Appolonia and Costanza Miliani
68 Amarilli Rava – UK (Winner Of The Session 2)
ADHESION INTERVENTIONS ON PAINT LAYERS
CORRELATING VISCOSITY AND SURFACE TENSION TO ADHESIVE
PENETRATION AND DEPOSITION
81
Francesco Abate - Italy
TOWARDS AN INNOVATIVE ANTI-CORROSION COATING
FOR METAL ARTWORKS BY COUPLING NANOTECHNOLOGY AND
GREEN CHEMISTRY
87
Astrid Sánchez Carrasco - Mexico
WATERCOLORS WASHING WITH PARAPRINT OL60 WASHING: ANALYTICAL STUDY
96
Royce Lyssah M. Malabonga - Philippines
FROM MATERIALITY TO IMMATERIALITY
ADOPTING TANGIBLE CULTURAL HERITAGE DOCUMENTATION
TECHNIQUES TO INTANGIBLE CULTURAL HERITAGE
98
Leticia Fundora Rangel- Cuba
STUDY OF POSSIBLE SOURCES OF VEGETABLE FIBERS IN CUBA
FOR THE HANDMADE ELABORATION OF USEFUL AND NECESSARY
PAPER FOR RESTORATION
104
Valeria Stagno - Italy
NMR PROTOCOL FOR MULTISCALE CHARACTERIZATION OF
ARCHAEOLOGICAL WATERLOGGED WOOD
106 SESSION 3
Sara Abram and Alberto Garlandini
109 Camila Silveira de Pinho – Brazil (Winner Of The Session 3) ICOM BRAZIL RECOMMENDATION IN FRONT OF TO COVID-19
117
Anna Andrzejewska - Poland
PLASTIC IN OUR CULTURAL HERITAGE
TRASH OR TREASURE? 124
Dafne Diamante -Nederland
FACING THE BACKLOG
THE PRINT ROOM ONLINE PROJECT FROM RIJKSMUSEUM IN
AMSTERDAM
132
Giulia Edimond, Mirko Giangrasso - Oman
THE BIRTH OF A MUSEUM: THE CONSERVATOR’S POINT OF VIEW
137 Martina Ferrari - USA
A NEW DIGITAL APPROACH IN TEXTILES DOCUMENTATION
INVESTIGATING SAFAVID VELVETS IN THE COLLECTION OF THE
UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA MUSEUM OF ARCHAEOLOGY AND
ANTHROPOLOGY [PENN MUSEUM]
150
Pamela Murray - UK
BUILDING A CULTURE OF CONSERVATION
A CASE STUDY MEASURING THE BENEFITS OF A GRANT-FUNDED
CONSERVATION PROJECT
156 SESSION 4
Stefania De Blasi and Maria Beatrice Failla
159 Alexandra Galitskaya – Italy (Winner Of The Session 4)
THE BIRTH AND DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC RESTORATION
FROM THE EIGHTEENTH TO THE EARLY TWENTIETH CENTURY IN
RUSSIA
164
Maria Canavan, Letizia Marcattili - Ireland
THE ROMAN SCHOOL AT THE NATIONAL GALLERY OF IRELAND
CONNECTING PAST AND PRESENT CONSERVATION PRACTICES
THROUGH THE TREATMENT OF A PAINTING BY LAVINIA FONTANA
171
Rosaria Garofalo - Italy
THE APOTHEOSIS OF SANTA BRIGIDA BY LUCA GIORDANO
COLLECTING UNPUBLISHED DOCUMENTS TO RECONSTRUCT ITS
CONSERVATION HISTORY THE RESTORATIONS OF YESTERDAY
AND TODAY COMPARED
180
Claudia Marchese - Italy
A HISTORY OF RESTORATION IN LUCCA FROM MICHELE RIDOLFI
UNTIL THE PRESENT
THE CASE OF A LARGE-SCALE PAINTING BY PIETRO PAOLINI
187
Maria Riccardi - Italy
THE 1932 RESTORATION OF APRILE BY FONTANESI
A CASE STUDY OF CONSERVATION, MUSEOLOGY, AND ART
CRITICISM
192
Jasmine Sartor - Italy
ANTIQUE ORIENTAL CARPETS
RESTORATION METHODOLOGIES FROM THE 19
TH
TO 20
TH
CENTURIES
T he first edition of the Young Professionals Forum was an edition born to welcome all the young participants as guests of our Center, to share thoughts and analysis together, in order to lay the foundations for building a community of young professionals of cultural heritage, a community that would have taken its first steps here, and would have grown over time to find itself enriched with new experiences and new resources, still with us, the following year. The health emergency due to the COVID epidemic, which unfortunately we all know, a few months earlier made us face a very difficult choice: we should have canceled the YPF or try instead to convert it into a digital forum, transforming a problem into an opportunity? We did not want to give up the possibility of gathering around our Center many young professionals of conservation and restoration, young people coming literally from all over the world, young people who could contribute, with their ideas and experiences, to develop an interdisciplinary platform for exchange and comparison, which in this complicated historical moment, we believe it’s more important than ever to plan and support. Our Center for fifteen years has dedicated all its resources to the care of the cultural, artistic and historical heritage, moreover we host the Degree Course in conservation and restoration of the University of Turin, which every year enriches the cultural heritage panorama (both in Italy and abroad) with new highly specialized professionals. It was therefore logical and natural for us to place among our main development objectives the organization of the Forum, which we wanted to represent the first international event focused on skills growth, comparison between industry professionals and opening to wider and more diversified audiences. The choice of the themes on which the four sections were based, arose from the need to broaden the scope of our reflection, stimulate synergies between preservation professionals, curators, art historians and scientists, and enhance the interdisciplinarity and the experiences of individual professionals in order to build a common vision. Now we know that the choice we made a few months ago was the right choice and we couldn’t be more proud to realise how many people were connected with us the 2nd of July and how incredibly high was the quality level of the abstracts that the young professionals submitted to the evaluation of our scientific committee, which I have to thank so much for the extraordinary work accomplished during these months. Furthermore, I couldn’t end without pointing out that we couldn’t have done all this without the support of Compagnia di San Paolo, which was the first one to believe in this project and its potential, and without the participation of our great international partners, ICOM, IIC, CNR, ICCROM and UniTo who immediately accepted this challenge. And finally, I really need to thank our Secretary-General, Sara Abram, who was the tireless engine and the real heart of this project, since its genesis. Stefano Trucco
CCR President
6
INSTITUTIONAL INTRODUCTION
7
C ompagnia di San Paolo is a private foundation and institution. It dates back in the XVI century, that means it has a long tradition of being part of the history of the Torino territory, and supporting arts and culture is one of its core activities where to deploy the money that we can put on the table, considering the results of our endowment. We are founding partners of the Centro Conservazione e Restauro “La Venaria Reale” and we see it with great favour because it’s an institution that has been able to consolidate its reputation in the scientific domain reaching significant achievements lately, in the last year. For this reason, the last year we decided to put additional money on the Centro to support its strategic multiannual plan in which one of the directories is the internationalisation. This today event is one of the main activities within this streamline. We consider that it can help in enhancing the attractivity of our territory, considering exactly the young professionals in this fascinating field of restoration in arts and culture and also considering Venaria and Torino as one of the reference points on the map for exchange among communities of professionals generating further opportunities and contributing under the supervision of the chairman Stefano Trucco and all the staff of the institution of research and education. I also mention the new secretary general, so an institution that has been able and is able to renew itself, to continue working along the line of excellence and so I’m very happy to be here today and to wish all of you a great job and a great meeting. Alberto Anfossi
Fondazione Compagnia di San Paolo
Secretary General
8
N owadays, the preservation, conservation and transmission of cultural heritage all demand a great deal of preparation: in technical adeptness, scientific disciplines and the humanities. But above all, we need to be interconnected, to know our own contexts and cultures well, and we need to fuse our different perspectives and to share our research and discoveries. These are the reasons why we created the Young Professionals Forum: from the very first steps, we envisioned a meeting rather than a scientific conference, a location (which has necessarily become virtual) in which to meet, establish relationships, swap experiences, and above all, our own visions. Working in conjunction with the scientific committee, every session has been dedicated to one of the following themes: Ethics and Practice of Restoration, Diagnostics and Technologies Applied to Conservation, Museum Professions and History of Conservation. We have deliberately focused the forum’s attention on the four general themes, four general categories in which everyone can freely express his or her own personality and point of view. The Forum aims to offer an open, inclusive platform for exchange, a place for the young people involved to compare experiences, research, perspectives, and expectations. The goal is for the new generations of professionals to become acquainted: in fact, in recent decades the growth in awareness, the level of technical-scientific training and the many opportunities for specialization have had a significant impact on the skills that today’s restorers, scientists and art historians can offer to conserve our cultural heritage. Today, our goal is to turn this event into the beginning of something new and we intend to work hard to keep this network alive and strong, offering its participants opportunities for training, keeping up to speed, and professional networking. We will be asking for your opinions and suggestions on the topics to be dealt with, trying to offer some answers to the needs that you consider priority. This publication, which gathers the presentations selected for the first edition of the Forum, is a basic way to contribute to knowledge of the most interesting contemporary issues. These essays also represent a sort of snapshot of “new skills in the conservation of cultural heritage”, as stated in the Forum’s pay-off. Sara Abram
CCR Secretary General
FOREWORD
9
W e live in an era facing profound social, environmental and technological changes. Changes which are affecting our ways of living. Which constantly push us to quickly update our knowledge, references and languages. And which also concern all the professions related to culture and its diverse expressions. In this scenario, it becomes important, more than ever, for those ones who work in the culture sector, and in particular for those ones engaged in training the cultural professions of the future, to understand the dynamics in progress and to identify and address the possible paths of innovation. On these convictions, when with the Santagata Foundation team we worked on drafting the Strategic Plan of the Fondazione Centro per la Conservazione e il Restauro dei beni culturali “La Venaria Reale”, it came pretty natural to conceptualize and ground all the development priorities of the plan on the evolution of the restorer profession. A profession that already today requires to acquire awareness and skills on many complex issues, much beyond the scientific ones. The professional figure of the restorer is in fact increasingly called by the competition to equip itself with multidisciplinary and trans-sectoral skills, to dialogue with a moltitude of actors, to move in international contexts, and to use technologically advanced tools. Among the measures proposed in the Strategic Plan, the Young Professionals Forum is certainly the one that is most explicitly aimed at working on the next future professionals of restoration. Investing in young people means in fact an opportunity to generate sharings, dialogue, alternative narratives. And, by doing this, an occasion for understanding the emerging geographies of restoration, new tools, languages, forms of production and conservation of cultural heritage. In other words, it aims at having a greater ability to perceive the evolution of the demand expressed by the sector and, consequently, to be better equipped to comply with it. The experience conducted with the first edition allowed already to draw a significative balance, and to collect inputs towards innovation to face the challenges of the evolving markets. Working on the continuity of the Forum, and building an effective community of knowledge and practice is now the next challenge. Alessio Re
Fondazione Santagata per l’Economia della Cultura Secretary General
INVESTING ON THE FUTURE
OF RESTORATION
OF CULTURAL HERITAGE
10
INTRODUCTION
I t is an honour for me today to have this opportunity to address the future and speak to young professionals, who are, in fact, the future of our profession. Today’s topic “From Conservation to Cultural Heritage Management” invites introspection. Allow me to recall at this point the Burra Charter, which describes conservation in terms of the protection and enhancement of cultural heritage. However, by conservation, we also mean techniques, methods, technologies and so on. Management is often interpreted as more than political decision making. In fact, over the years, conservation has increasingly been integrated into the management of cultural heritage and this has marked the evolution of ICCROM. This shift is in response to the challenges of the globalization of cultural heritage. This evolution began in the aftermath of the Second World War, when the emphasis was placed on the protection of monuments and sites, as well as the finds in museums, and the emphasis was placed on physical intervention, aimed at ensuring the restoration of objects, buildings and monuments in their original state, according to the principles of the Venice Charter for the care of cultural heritage and implementation of restoration processes. The Charter introduces the concept of significant issues, those that absolutely must be examined. It also contextualizes the cultural heritage in relation to its conservation and protection. It also takes into consideration the intangible aspects of cultural heritage, showing itself to be more complex, more complete if you prefer. At the beginning of its activities, 60 years ago, the “Rome Centre”, as ICCROM was then called, was aimed at providing advice and developing training modules on the technical aspects of conservation. Today, ICCROM, with an office in Rome and a regional office in the Emirate of Sharjah and with more than 137 Member States, has enriched its capacity to assist member countries. But there is also another important aspect to consider: what are the different voices of heritage? Laurajane Smith developed the concept of “authorized heritage”, but there is also “unauthorized heritage”. Communities involved in heritage management - and no longer just heritage professionals - have begun to consider cultural heritage issues. In other words, who defines the assets? If we reflect on the recent events of the pandemic, we understand how much the monuments or the collections themselves are linked to well-being, and the fundamental role they play in society. Cultural heritage is in the interest of the communities living on the sites, but also of those whose life and activity is conditioned by the cultural heritage itself. We think of the closure in recent months of places of cultural heritage and the effect it has on people’s well-being. Emphasizing the importance of cultural heritage within society is no longer something we can ignore, as it has an impact on how we create the next generation, the younger generation taking the place of
11 current professionals. It is no longer just about training, but about the development of social skills and the ability to listen to different voices. The management of a site cannot ignore the socio-economic and environmental aspects. Preservation now requires a much more holistic approach. The events triggered by COVID-19 have made us aware of the need to cooperate and the fundamental role of cultural heritage in post-pandemic reconstruction. ICCROM has appealed to governments, institutions and individuals to consider cultural heritage as essential for the recovery of communities. ICCROM has also launched a webinar programme and, although this is a solution eminently dictated by necessity, I believe that it allows us, in reality, to democratize knowledge and, consequently, the knowledge of cultural heritage, permitting, as in today’s event, a large presence from all over the world. Movements like Black Lives Matter can also affect cultural heritage. In fact, it is not just a question of the subject itself but of the fact that it is a problem that concerns us, such as the statues that are destroyed. What we need to understand is how to deal with these situations and, above all, how to listen to other voices, other than the dominant voice, in what we do, in our studies or in our practice. If we can do this, I think heritage conservation and management will be in a better position to build the future. Webber Ndoro
ICCROM General Director
CONSERVATION
ETHICS
AND PRACTICE
Michela Cardinali
Sarah Stannage
SESSION 1
13
T he decision-making process which accompanies the choices to conserve cultural heritage on a daily basis needs an unflagging acceptance of ethical and moral responsibility with respect to the future life of artefacts, finds, sites/monuments, and all the testimonies which characterize our cultural and historical memory. It is precisely the importance of this critical act which led to the theme of ethics being included in the act of conservation in a dedicated area of the Young Professionals Forum. This proposal, welcomed by the participants at the international meeting, made it possible to quickly shape the relationship existing today between the theory and practice of conservation and an initial rapprochement of technical-operational data to the values conveyed by the interventions themselves. In this highly particular historical, cultural and economic moment caused by the ongoing pandemic, it is necessary to re-establish continuity with these values and to animate the comparison and connection between the professions, eliminating the distances that have suddenly been generated. The reality is that distances do exist and can have different origins and duration, but they can nonetheless be overcome through our ability to evolve and innovate ourselves and our way of operating and living our profession. Consequently, the Young Professionals Forum represents a real opportunity to concretely respond to this need for innovation and evolution of the discipline and to achieve the important goal of intercultural aggregation of young professionals from our scientific community. The aim is to meet new allies and colleagues to rely on and collaborate with for the conservation of our cultural heritage and for the development of and interconnection between the different disciplines. The potential offered by the forum was well understood by many young people, who sent their contributions and shared their experiences with us, fully grasping the spirit of this forum and the opportunity for connection and exchange. The selection of the contributions was approached as a reinterpretation of the moral thinking and ethical criterion related to the different operational contexts and was carried out in a spirit of synergy and comparison by Sarah Stannage (IIC, International Institute for Conservation, Executive Director). Despite the
14 distances, differing experiences and skills involved, we reached the end of our selection process with the same list of names, finding ourselves faced by a very interesting critical and methodological scenario. In fact, the contributions selected also allowed us to constructively raise questions about aspects which unite and differentiate us in the methodological and technical spheres. Conservation and restoration have always been understood in very different ways depending on the sociocultural context and the evolution of conservation and restoration theories. In this sense, the contributions proposed in this thematic area allow us to get to know this richness and variety of experiences and to share the intercultural panorama of the ethical concept. From moments of crisis, such as the one we are experiencing, we can grasp the opportunity to question our ways of thinking, but also living, ethics, pushing ourselves towards new perspectives. With greater exchange and synergy between professions and specializations, the development of our discipline is guaranteed, achieving a shared conservation practice which can enhance exchanges between cultures. The ethical principles on which the interdisciplinary relationships necessary for the conservation of Cultural Heritage must be based include respect for cultural diversity, intercultural inclusion, and education in the sense of belonging and the sharing of data, to promote the development of both innovation and research. Finally, to the young professionals who make up our community of practice and who have actively participated in the forum, I would like to suggest: - promote a responsible ethical approach to the heritage of art, technical knowledge, stories and memories; - open your minds and show your sensitivity; - strengthen identity and relations by promoting intercultural inclusion and accessibility to knowledge. Michela Cardinali
15
D uring what has been one of the most challenging periods in living memory, there are many dimensions to the Covid-19 pandemic and its impacts on a world already feeling the effects of climate change. While the impacts will be felt for many months, if not years to come, these challenges are bringing us together in solidarity internationally by increasing our shared collective experiences during these times of isolation. As we enter a new territory for conservation, IIC acknowledges and applauds the perseverance and generosity shown over these last few months to contribute to discussions on conservation ethics and practice. More specifically, the focus created by the Young Professionals Forum (YPF) on this theme provides an opportunity for critical reflection from within the field. This in turn gives an opportunity to explore the role of conservators in a changing society. It is both the moral basis defined by the codes of ethics together with the analytical, scientific and often interdisciplinary approach that underlies conservation, providing evidences of past knowledge, and the ways by which these maybe conveyed into the future. Exploring the tangible as well as intangible will require conservators to engage not only with multidisciplinary methods but also multidisciplinary communities to understand the meanings and values which they seek to preserve, leading to questions regarding the purposes of conservation itself. The critical thoughts and decision-making processes framed by conservation ethics and practice are embodied within the selected papers and are ultimately captured by the shared vision of this forum to create a common understanding among conservators, scientists, art historians, curators, cultural heritage professionals around the world. Sarah Stannage
16
INTRODUCTION
Built in dry-stone walling architecture, Great Zimbabwe (20˚ 16’ 60” S, 30˚ 55’ 60” E) is one of the largest and famous archaeological sites in sub-Saharan Africa. The site is administered by the National Museums and Monuments of Zimbabwe (NMMZ), a parastatal under the Ministry of Home Affairs and Cultural Heritage. It is was gazetted as a national monument in 1937 and enlisted on the United Nations Educational and Cultural Organisation’s (UNESCO) World Heritage List in 1986. The site is located in south-central Zimbabwe, 27km east of the city of Masvingo. Since the late 18 th centuries up to the present, Great Zimbabwe has been subjected to both amateurish and professional multi-disciplinary investigations concerning who built it, how, when and why the state later on collapsed around the 16 th century 1 . Today an enormous corpus of academic literature is available on Great Zimbabwe in comparison to other similar archaeological sites in southern Africa. This scenario often provides a misleading impression that almost every aspect of the site has been extensively researched and INDIGENOUS
KNOWLEDGE
SKILLS AND
PRACTICES
IN CONSERVING DRY-STONE WALLS
AT GREAT ZIMBABWE WORLD
HERITAGE SITE
1. Conservation ethics and practice
Munyaradzi Elton Sagiya mesagiya@gmail.com Zimbabwe
Munyaradzi Elton Sagiya
PhD Candidate - University of Zimbabwe and Curator - National Museums and
Monuments of Zimbabwe
WINNER OF THE SESSION 1
17 published. However, relying on my work experience at the site as well as review of literature, there are still gaps in knowledge about Great Zimbabwe and how to conserve its material remains, in particular the dry-stone built architecture. One of the unexplored key research issues pertains to what has been the role of indigenous knowledge, skills and practices in the conservation of the dry-stone walls which constitute the major physical fabric of the site (fig. 1). This question arises against the background of the scholarship’s emphasises on privileging ‘western’ or ‘scientific’ knowledgies and conservation approaches 2 , often ignoring the local expertise and practices. In this article, I examine and explore the contribution of traditional stonemasons towards the conservation of dry-stone walls at Great Zimbabwe. GREAT ZIMBABWE: A DRY-STONE BUILT CULTURAL HERITAGE
There are more than 360 similar dry-stone built archaeological sites of varying sizes, types and significance, predominately located in Zimbabwe with few in neighbouring countries of Botswana, Mozambique and South Africa (fig. 2). These archaeological sites monumentalise the development of the complex state societies that were established and flourished between 11 th and 18 th centuries in southern Africa 3 . However, prior to the extensive researches by archaeologists and other scholars from related disciplines, places such as Great Zimbabwe were interpreted…